Already have an account?
Get back to the
Food & Recipes

This Classic Condiment is the Key to the Creamiest Mashed Potatoes

Tags:

Perfectly creamy mashed potatoes are like a work of art. Smoothing out all the lumps is one thing, but getting the ratio of milk and butter just right is its own sort of magic. So when I stumbled upon a recipe that omits both of those ingredients in favor of mayonnaise, I was intrigued, but with a healthy dose of skepticism. 

Mayo is a classic condiment I always have in my fridge — we even combine it with potatoes to make potato salad — but forgoing butter and milk seemed risky. Let me start by saying, mashed potatoes mean a lot to me. Not just because they’re delicious, but I have many happy memories whipping them up with my mom as a kid. We’d always sneak a few bites of earthy raw spuds before tossing them into the pot of water — that’s how much I love potatoes. 

Despite my apprehension, I decided to give it a shot and grabbed a couple of medium-sized potatoes, peeled and chopped them up, and threw them in some boiling water. The recipe, from Hellmann’s Mayonnaise, called for a half a cup of the condiment and an optional tablespoon of milk. It seemed like a lot of mayo to me, so I started by adding about two-thirds of that amount into my pile of mashed taters. It wasn’t quite the level of creaminess I was hoping for, so I lopped the whole thing in. 

Mayo mashed potatoes

(Photo Credit: FirstForWomen.com)

I went ahead and added the milk (and just a dash of salt and pepper) to really see how smooth they could get. Turns out Hellmann’s was onto something — the combo of mayo and just a splash of milk got them to a creamy perfection. I have to add way more milk with my traditional recipe, so that was definitely a surprise. 

Of course, the question you’re probably most curious about is: How did they taste? It certainly had a mayo-y flavor — there’s no getting around it with that much of the condiment mixed in — but it wasn’t bad at all. In fact, I really liked the extra zing! I had my roommate take a bite and she was a fan, too. 

Mashed potatoes with mayo

(Photo Credit: FirstForWomen.com)

If you like mayo and want to use less butter and save on milk without sacrificing the creaminess of your mashed potatoes, this trick can definitely help you achieve a scrumptious side dish. 

Use left and right arrow keys to navigate between menu items. Use right arrow key to move into submenus. Use escape to exit the menu. Use up and down arrow keys to explore. Use left arrow key to move back to the parent list.