Already have an account?
Get back to the

These 4-Slice Toasters Turn Out Perfectly Golden Bread for a Crowd


First For Women has affiliate partnerships. We receive compensation when you click on a link and make a purchase. Learn more!

Toasters are some of the most common kitchen appliances there are — a kitchen just isn’t a kitchen without one! They’re not hard to find, so buying a new one may sound like a simple enough task. When you’re looking for a 4-slice toaster to feed the whole family in the morning though — some of whom prefer frozen waffles, some who want crispy English muffins, and others who love chewy bagels, it can be a little harder to find the toaster of your dreams.

With many different factors to consider and reviews to pore over, choosing the best toaster for your household can quickly become a confusing chore. That’s why we’ve given you a head start by finding some of the best 4-slice toasters on the market! Narrowing it down to your favorite will be much easier when you pick from the models below. Keep scrolling to shop FIRST for Women’s picks for the best 4-slice toasters you can buy.

Why buy a 4-slice toaster? 

For a large family, or anyone who frequently hosts a crowd at breakfast time, a 4-slice toaster is a must-have. Being able to toast extra slices prevents a toaster traffic jam and keeps everyone moving in the morning — and the best 4-slice toasters can handle bagels, thick sourdough slices, frozen waffles, or anything else you’d like to warm up.

There are a few key factors you’ll want to look for while on the hunt for the perfect toaster, including the width of the bread slots (will it be able to toast that monster bagel?), special pre-sets (can it warm or defrost bread?), browning settings (all the better to crisp your toast to your liking), and crumb trays for easy cleanup. There are even smart toasters available these days that can automatically lower your bread down into the machine!

Whether you’re shopping for a simple, affordable 4-slice toaster that will simply add some crunch to your bread or a fancy, splurge-worthy option, we’ve got you covered.

Smeg Retro 4-Slice Toaster

smeg 4 slice toaster

Where to buy: $249.99, Amazon

Why we like it:

  • Cute retro style, available in 7 colors
  • Dual toasting controls with 4 functions and 6 browning levels

We can’t get enough of this adorable Smeg toaster, which comes in an array of fun pastels as well as a chrome option. It’s more than cute though — it’s a seriously functional toasting machine! The four large toast slots accommodate bagels and thick slices, and dual independent controls let you choose from features such as reheat, defrost, and bagel function, as well as six different levels of done-ness. Toast (or waffles, or bagels, or whatever) automatically pops up when it’s done, so you don’t have to worry about setting the smoke alarm off. And a removable crumb tray makes for easy cleaning!

Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Classic 4-Slice Toaster

cuisinart 4 slice toaster

Where to buy: $69.95, Amazon

Why we like it:

  • Brushed stainless steel housing
  • Wide slots

There’s a reason Cuisinart is a trusted name in household appliances, and this toaster is no exception. With over 7,000 Amazon reviews and a 4.5-star rating, you know there are plenty of satisfied customers out there, enjoying perfectly-toasted English muffins, toast, and bagels. Wide slots, an extra-lift lever that pops the toast high enough to reach it, an easy slide-out crumb tray, and two independently operating six-setting browning dials make breakfast easy, no matter how many are crowded around the toaster!

CUSINAID Wide Slot Toaster

cusinaid 4 slice toaster

Where to buy: Amazon, $59.99

Why we like it:

  • Hundreds of five-star Amazon reviews
  • High-lift lever makes it easy to reach small slices

Is there anything more irritating in the morning than when your bread gets caught in the toaster and you can’t fish it out? This Cusinaid toaster has the solution: an automatic pop-up feature with a lever that lifts your toast extra-high, so even the smallest slices won’t get lost in the depths. With seven shades to choose from, your bread will get the perfect color of toastiness you prefer, and this machine toasts both sides quickly and evenly, thanks to 1400 watts of power. Two removable crumb trays ensure easy cleanup, as well!

Krups KH734D Toaster

krups 4 slice toaster

Where to buy: $64.99, Amazon

Why we like it:

  • Simple design
  • Great reviews

This Krups toaster has everything you need, and nothing you don’t. Dual control toasting, so two people can toast their bread to their own taste at the same time, extra large slots to handle any bagel you want to toast, and six browning settings. It defrosts frozen waffles and pastries, has a removable crumb tray, and has thousands of glowing Amazon reviews. What more do you need? Just butter, and maybe a great cup of coffee.

Cusibox 4-Slice Toaster

cuisibox 4 slice toaster

Where to buy: $59.99, Amazon

Why we like it:

  • Great reviews
  • Wide slots

A sleek, simple design and reliable functionality have earned this affordable CUSIBOX stainless steel toaster a solid 4.5-star Amazon rating. Six browning settings, plus special bagel and defrost options ensure that your bread, bagels, or English muffins will come out at the perfect crispness. Each of its four slots is 1.5 inches wide and have a self-centering guide for even toasting, every time. A handy high lift lever helps you remove smaller slices safely, while two crumb trays, which easily slide out from the bottom, make cleanup completely hassle-free. 

Use left and right arrow keys to navigate between menu items. Use right arrow key to move into submenus. Use escape to exit the menu. Use up and down arrow keys to explore. Use left arrow key to move back to the parent list.